Probably Stolen Blue Labeler vs Red Labeler
What the blue and red labelers do in Probably Stolen, how they differ, and which parts are official, which are player reports, and which nobody has pinned down yet.
The blue labeler renames items. The red labeler changes the label that states an item’s quality or authenticity: counterfeit to genuine and back, or the grade shown on water. Players tie water grades to the red one by name; for counterfeit and genuine, the sources describe a labeler without naming its colour, and this page matches that job to the red one.
One Demo-era player says you get the red labeler free, and a 1.0 guide says the tutorial gives you a label printer that switches items between counterfeit and genuine, which matches the red one. One player says they bought the blue one. Everything players say about the blue labeler comes from before 1.0, from the Playtest and the Demo; this site found no 1.0 report about it.
Evidence level: Community reported Not site-tested What each labeler does comes from Steam community posts and one community achievement guide, not from the developer, and this site has not reproduced any of it in game. The blue labeler rests on two players, one writing during the Playtest and one during the Demo. The red labeler’s job has four community sources, two from 1.0 and two from the Demo; the two 1.0 sources do not name a colour. Facts with only one source are marked Single source.
Confirmed Three official facts are marked Confirmed where they appear: the Demo-era patch notes that introduced the Toolbox, the 1.0 Steam achievement list, and the official Steam store description, which carries no version label. Last verified: 2026-11-03.
Blue vs red labeler at a glance
| Blue labeler | Red labeler | |
|---|---|---|
| What it changes | The item’s name Community reported Pre-1.0 | The quality or authenticity label: counterfeit or genuine, the grade of water — colour matched by function for counterfeit/genuine Community reported |
| How you get it | One Demo-era player says they bought it; where and for how much is not reported Single source | Free, says a Demo-era player. A 1.0 guide says the tutorial, or skipping the opening, gives you a label printer that switches counterfeit and genuine; it names no colour, but that is the red one’s job Community reported |
| Latest report found | Demo, 2026-10-23 | 1.0, 2026-11-02 |
What the blue labeler does
Community reported Pre-1.0 Two players, both writing before the 1.0 release, tie the blue labeler to changing an item’s name. During the Playtest, one player wondered whether the blue labeler was meant to change the name of items “to pull a fast one”. In a Demo feedback thread, a second player called it “the blue renaming gun” and said the game does not explain it.
The same Demo-era player says the red labeler is free, while the blue one was something they bought, and that after buying it the blue one seemed useless to them Single source. Their post does not say where they bought it or what it cost, and this site found no source that does.
In another Demo-era thread about labelling, one player asked whether marking storage containers needs the blue labeler. That was a question, not a report, so this page does not count it as evidence.
This site found no report about the blue labeler from after the 1.0 release on 28 October 2026. Treat everything in this section as pre-1.0 behaviour that the release may have changed.
What the red labeler does
Community reported The red labeler changes the label that states an item’s quality or authenticity. In the Demo, the player who called the blue one a renaming gun says you get the red one free “to alter the water rating”, and in the labelling thread AirspeedVelocityOfASwallow says they made a habit of keeping the red one because water was “not always updating when filtered”, adding that a then-recent patch letting the water tester “match label” made that less necessary.
Two 1.0 sources describe the same job without naming a colour. The achievement guide by 4mb1t10nX says the label printer you get can be used on items that have a quality to change their label, and gives cigarettes as its example: a counterfeit pack can be relabelled as genuine, and the other way round. A player reply from 1.0 lists using the labeller to set water to pure, chems to lab pure and cigarettes to genuine. This page matches those two to the red labeler by what they describe.
Players say you do not have to buy it. The Demo-era player says the red one is free, and the 1.0 achievement guide says you receive a label printer in the tutorial or when you skip the opening Community reported. The guide names no colour; this page matches its label printer to the red labeler because it switches counterfeit and genuine labels.
Situations players mention
- Goods bought with the wrong label. In the opening post of the labelling thread, Cecilff2 describes buying cigarettes marked counterfeit that turned out to be genuine, and points out that after the purchase you cannot mark them as genuine without a labeler (the post does not say which labeler) Single source Pre-1.0.
- Water labels. One 1.0 player says water does not usually change its displayed name until something relabels it: test kits, an aqua scanner, a chem scanner and the labeler can all do that, though the labeler lets you lie (they do not say which one) Single source. Testing, grades and purifying are in the water guide.
Related, but not a labeler use: in the same thread, AirspeedVelocityOfASwallow says that if a seller has marked the cigarettes you are about to buy as counterfeit, you have the option to tell the seller they are actually genuine for a boost to reputation, and warns that they might really be counterfeit. The post does not tie this to a labeler Single source Pre-1.0.
Telling a fake from a genuine item is a separate job: the appraisal guide covers the counterfeit checks for Ribwich and Immunivax.
The risk of selling fake labels
Confirmed According to the official Steam store description, you can cut a product’s quality, relabel counterfeit products as genuine, or fence discounted stolen goods if you believe Security won’t reach you. Relabelling a fake as genuine is part of the game as the developer describes it. The description does not name a labeler or say what happens when a fake label is caught.
Single source On the risk, one 1.0 player writes that “any fake labeled item sold has a chance of people discovering it being wrong the next day of 8% per markup you made”. That is the only source for it, the wording does not make clear how “per markup” is counted, and this site has not tested it, so this page does not turn it into a formula. Player reports on mislabelled water are collected in the water guide.
The Toolbox and the labeler achievement
Confirmed Demo-era The developer’s UPDATE 049 Patch note - Release Date + New Demo notes of 2026-09-14, released with the Demo, say that equip mode for selectable items lets tools be used quickly on multiple items, and a new Toolbox stores tools, including the blue and red labelers; keys 1 to 9 equip the corresponding tool. The Toolbox can be bought from Dr. Jackson after day 14. This is also the official confirmation that the game has both a blue and a red labeler. The notes predate 1.0, and this site has not checked whether the Toolbox, its key bindings or the day-14 timing changed in the release.
Confirmed The 1.0 Steam achievement list includes Lower Levels Special: “Change the label of any item using the labeler.” The description does not say which labeler counts, and the list gives no other unlock steps.
What is still unknown
| Question | Current evidence |
|---|---|
| Where do you get the blue labeler, and what does it cost? Unknown | One Demo-era player says they bought it. No source found here names a seller or a price. |
| Did 1.0 change the blue labeler? Unknown | Every report about it is from the Playtest or the Demo. |
| Does the achievement need a particular labeler? Unknown | Its description says only “the labeler”. |
| Is the Toolbox still sold by Dr. Jackson after day 14? Unknown | That comes from the Demo-era notes and has not been re-checked in 1.0. |
| How likely is a fake label to be caught? Single source | One 1.0 player gives 8% per markup for discovery the next day, in loose wording. No second source. |
Sources and version
The blue labeler reports date from the Playtest (2026-08-08) and the Demo (2026-10-23). The red labeler reports run from the Demo (2026-10-22 and 2026-10-23) to 1.0: a guide published on 2026-10-30 and updated on 2026-11-01, and two player replies dated 2026-11-02. Steam dates on this page are as Steam shows them, in Pacific time. Probably Stolen 1.0 was released on 28 October 2026. Sources were last checked on 2026-11-03, and a game update can change any of this.
Left out on purpose: ideas players have suggested for the blue labeler but not reported doing, and claims without a traceable source. Anything marked Community reported or Single source moves up only once this site has a screenshot or a further independent report behind it.
Probably Stolen labeler FAQ
What does the blue labeler do in Probably Stolen?
It changes an item’s name, according to two players writing before the 1.0 release: one during the Playtest and one during the Demo, who called it the blue renaming gun. The Demo player also says the game does not explain it and that it seemed useless to them after they bought it. This site found no report about the blue labeler from 1.0, so the release may have changed it, and no source says where to get it or what it costs.
What is the difference between the blue and red labeler?
The blue labeler renames items, according to two pre-1.0 players. The red labeler changes the label that states an item’s quality or authenticity: counterfeit or genuine, or the grade of water. Four community sources describe that job, two of them from 1.0, although the two 1.0 sources do not name a colour. One Demo-era player says you get the red labeler free, and a 1.0 guide says the tutorial gives you a label printer that switches items between counterfeit and genuine, which matches the red one by what it does. One Demo-era player says they bought the blue one.
Can you relabel counterfeit items as genuine in Probably Stolen?
Yes. The official Steam store description lists relabelling counterfeit products as genuine as one of your options, and players describe the labeler doing exactly that. One 1.0 player warns that any item sold with a fake label has a chance of being discovered the next day, which they give as 8% per markup you made. That is a single, loosely worded report that this site has not tested.
How do you get the labelers in Probably Stolen?
A Demo-era player says the red labeler is free, and a 1.0 achievement guide says you receive a label printer in the tutorial or when you skip the opening. The guide does not name a colour; the printer it describes switches items between counterfeit and genuine, which is the red labeler’s job. For the blue labeler, one Demo-era player says they bought it, but no source found here says where or for how much. The developer’s Demo-era notes say a Toolbox, sold by Dr. Jackson after day 14, stores both labelers.
Is there an achievement for using the labeler?
Yes. Lower Levels Special, on the official 1.0 Steam achievement list, reads: Change the label of any item using the labeler. The description does not say which labeler counts.
Related pages
- Appraisal and counterfeit checks— how to tell a fake Ribwich or Immunivax before you buy it.
- Water guide— testing strips, purity grades and what players report about mislabelled water.
- All published guides— the current index.
Sources
- 4mb1t10nX — 中文100%全成就攻略 (achievement guide), Steam Community — independent 1.0 community guide, published 2026-10-30 and updated 2026-11-01; the label printer you receive in the tutorial or by skipping the opening, used to switch an item between counterfeit and genuine. It does not name a colour.
- A reply in “## 20 Hours In – Great Game…”, Steam Community discussion — 1.0, thread dated 2026-11-02; one player’s reply on using the labeller for water, chems and cigarettes, and the 8% per markup discovery chance quoted above. It does not name a colour.
- Feedback & Questions — Steam Community discussion — 1.0; thread posted 2026-10-31, quoted reply by Darkseed dated 2026-11-02 Pacific time (2026-11-03 01:37 UTC); one player on water display names, the tools that change them and the labeler.
- Finally found a less manipulative use for label maker — Steam Community discussion — Demo era, 2026-10-22 and 2026-10-23, before 1.0; four players. The opening post by Cecilff2: you can’t mark goods genuine after purchase without a labeler. Reply #1 by Metro Gnome Holding Metronome only says to mark storage containers too. Reply #2 by AirspeedVelocityOfASwallow: keeping the red labeler because filtered water did not always update its label, and telling a seller that cigarettes marked counterfeit are actually genuine for reputation. Reply #3 by QOQ asks whether storage containers need the blue labeler and is not counted as a source.
- My thoughts after 8.5 hours — Steam Community discussion, Demo Feedback — Demo era, 2026-10-23; the blue renaming gun, the red labeler being free for water ratings, and buying the blue one.
- Share your feedback about the game! — Steam Community discussion, page 3, reply #38 by Oatamer — Playtest era, 2026-08-08; the blue labeler and changing item names.
- UPDATE 049 Patch note - Release Date + New Demo — official announcement, 2026-09-14, published with the Demo; the Toolbox that stores the blue and red labelers, its number-key bindings and its sale by Dr. Jackson after day 14
- Probably Stolen achievements — Steam Community — official Steam achievement list, checked 2026-11-02 — the source for the Lower Levels Special description quoted above
- Probably Stolen on Steam — official store description; relabelling counterfeit products as genuine