Probably Stolen Appraisal Guide

Appraisal values and counterfeit checks in Probably Stolen: Hands, Plasma Cartridges, Ribwich, Immunivax, Food Stamps and Hemingway Cigarettes. The rules below come from community references, with their evidence limits and disagreements shown.

Checking a specific item? Jump to Food Stamps or Hemingway Cigarettes.

Direct answer · Community reported

The three item types valued below use a base value, plus or minus a fixed amount for each feature, never below a minimum. Cybernetic Hands start from their material (100, 150 or 300) and cannot fall below 50. Plasma Cartridges start at 300. Ribwiches start at 150 and cannot fall below 40, and a fake one is worth 40.

For an Immunivax injector, check the serial number first: seven digits, no letters. Its first three digits are the batch, and batches 250, 251, 301, 355, 385, 386 and 421 are recalled.

Evidence level: Community reported Not site-tested The original item-value and counterfeit rules come from community tools and videos, not from the developer, and this site has not reproduced them in game. The three sources for those rules are Recreational Suffering’s web tool and its demo video, which count as one source because they share an author; Minder43’s calculator; and a Playtest-era video by Piranowsky. Where a rule rests on one of them alone it is marked Single source. The Food Stamp and cigarette additions cite their own references below. Last verified: 2026-11-06 for those two additions; the original valuation and Immunivax checks were last reviewed on 2026-11-02.

How appraisal works

Customers bring items for you to appraise. You inspect the item, work out its value from what you see, and send an estimate. The video by Recreational Suffering shows the game rating an estimate right after it is sent, at 00:06:44. Hands, Plasma Cartridges and Ribwiches all follow the same pattern: a base value, a fixed adjustment for each feature, and a floor the total cannot go below. Recreational Suffering’s tool says its data comes from the 1.0 release build of 28 October 2026, and in places it notes where the game behaves differently from the in-game guide. Immunivax is different: there you are checking whether the injector is genuine and usable, not putting a price on it.

Appraisal is one of the income lines covered in the money and shop-buyout guide; this page is the rule reference behind it.

How to get appraisal customers

Two community guides written for 1.0 describe the same access steps: accept the appraisal committee’s invitation and pay to join, then put the membership certificate in your display case. Keeping it in your files does not display it to customers. The early-game guide reports an invitation on day 8 for an Apprentice start on the challenge difficulty; the achievement guide says about day 5 without stating a difficulty. These are reports of different runs, not a guaranteed visit schedule.

If you have joined but have not displayed the certificate, check that first. These two guides do not establish a customer arrival probability, and this site has not tested display-sign priority. The first-days guide puts the invitation alongside scavenging, rent and power costs.

Cybernetic Hand values

Recreational Suffering’s tool and Minder43’s calculator give identical figures for every row below. Piranowsky’s Playtest video, from 00:06:59, gives the same numbers for the entries it covers: carbon composite at +50 over aluminum, Neural +120, unspecified −60, damaged −85, armor as an add-on and the minimum of 50.

FeatureOptionValue
Material Community reportedAluminum alloy100 base
Carbon composite150 base (+50)
Gold plated300 base (+200)
Control interface Community reportedNeural+120
EMG++45
EMG0
Unspecified−60
Condition Community reportedNo wear or damage0
Wear−35
Damage−85
Add-ons Community reportedArmored+50
Blade+80
Minimum Community reportedAny hand50

Tactical and Deluxe set bonuses

Two set bonuses sit on top of the table. Recreational Suffering’s tool and Minder43’s calculator give the same conditions for both:

SetBonusEvery condition must hold
Tactical Community reported+100Carbon composite; EMG+ or Neural interface; no wear or damage; both armor and a blade
Deluxe Community reported+200Gold plated; Neural interface; no wear or damage. Add-ons do not matter: the tool says with or without, and the calculator does not check them.

Our reading of those conditions, not a sourced claim: because Tactical needs carbon composite and Deluxe needs gold plating, one hand can never get both.

Plasma Cartridge values and manufacturer seals

The cartridge figures below come from Recreational Suffering’s tool and Minder43’s calculator, which agree on every adjustment and on the minimum; their only disagreement is the seal wear rule covered below. Piranowsky’s Playtest video also appraises cartridges, from 00:32:40, but with smaller figures than both tools, so cartridge values may have changed since the Playtest. Its cartridge numbers are not used here.

FeatureOptionValue
Base Community reportedAny cartridge300
Casing wear Community reportedLight wear−45
Heavy wear−90
Casing Community reportedCracked−150
Exposed screws−30
Reinforced+60
Plasma colour Community reportedLow grade−150
Standard0
High grade+150
Minimum Community reportedAny cartridge90

The seal from the cartridge’s manufacturer adds a bonus, but only when the cartridge meets that manufacturer’s conditions. If it does not, the seal adds nothing. Both tools give the same bonuses and the same conditions on colour, cracks, screws and reinforcement:

SealBonusConditions both tools giveCasing wear
WLD Community reported+60Standard or low-grade plasmaNot a condition
RNR Community reported+120Standard plasma; no crackNot a condition
ZHS Community reported+120Standard plasma; no crack; no exposed screws. Reinforced is fine.Sources disagree, see below
IGN Community reported+750High-grade plasma; no crack; no exposed screws; not reinforcedSources disagree, see below

On the IGN reinforcement rule, Recreational Suffering’s tool adds that the in-game cartridge appraisal guide does not mention it Single source. Minder43’s calculator applies the same rule without comment.

Does casing wear cancel the ZHS and IGN bonuses?

Sources disagree. Community reported Recreational Suffering’s tool gives the ZHS (+120) and IGN (+750) bonuses only to a cartridge with no wear, on top of the conditions in the table. In Minder43’s calculator, wear plays no part in either seal: a worn cartridge that meets the other conditions still gets the bonus. Both are community tools, and this site cannot say which one matches the game.

What to do: our suggestion, not a sourced rule, is to appraise conservatively. When you are buying a ZHS or IGN cartridge with any casing wear, price it without the seal bonus, so the worst case is that you underpaid. On IGN that gap is 750, more than the cartridge’s whole base value. The rating the game gives your estimate is the likeliest way to settle it: if you appraise worn ZHS or IGN cartridges, try the estimate both ways over several of them and note which one rates better.

Ribwich: counterfeit checks and value

Check for a fake before you add anything up, because a counterfeit Ribwich is worth a flat 40 whatever else it has. Every tell below is in Recreational Suffering’s tool. Minder43’s calculator gives the same year, facility and sesame-and-pickles rules, but it does not reliably check the logo or the sticker, so for those two the second source is Piranowsky’s Playtest video.

A genuine Ribwich then starts at 150. Both tools agree on every row in the next table. Piranowsky’s Playtest video, from 00:13:03, gives the same figures for what it covers: the 150 start, the 40 minimum, +80 for the first run, +50 for 1/425 or 12/438, facility numbers only up to 35 with ±50 adjustments, +300 for sesame with extra pickles, and +800 for a double patty.

FeatureConditionValue
Base Community reportedGenuine, packaging intact150
First production run Community reportedYear 425–429+80
First or last month Community reportedDated 1/425 or 12/438+50
Packing facility Community reported1, 2, 5, 8, 21 or 34+50
7, 15, 18, 26 or 31−50
Sesame bun with extra pickles Community reportedBoth present+300
Double meat patty Community reportedTwo patties+800 (Recreational Suffering shows it as a 950 base)
Counterfeit or bad packaging Community reportedAny tell above40, fixed
Minimum Community reportedAny Ribwich40

Immunivax: counterfeit checklist

Single source This whole section comes from one source: Recreational Suffering’s tool and its demo video from 00:01:38, which share an author and count once. Neither of the other two sources covers Immunivax, as far as this site found, and this site has not checked an injector itself.

Immunivax is a counterfeit check rather than a valuation. Work through the injector in this order:

  1. Serial number. It must be exactly seven digits. Any letter, or no serial number at all, means a counterfeit.
  2. Batch number. The first three digits of the serial are the batch. A genuine batch falls between 125 and 455, so a real serial number lies between 1250000 and 4559999; a batch outside that range means a counterfeit. Batches 250, 251, 301, 355, 385, 386 and 421 are on the recall list. The tool treats a recalled injector as unusable rather than counterfeit.
  3. Product name. It must read Immunivax, with the same capitals. Fakes reported by the tool include ImmuniVax 3000, Immunevax and Immunovax.
  4. Maker’s name. Compare it letter by letter with the in-game Immunivax guide. The tool gives the genuine spelling as Carmicheal Pharmaceutical, with nothing added, and lists fakes that add a word or drop letters, such as Carmicheal Pharmaceutical Ltd. and Crmichal Pharmaceutical. The video’s automatic captions spell it Carmichael, which captions cannot settle, so trust the in-game guide over either spelling here.
  5. Body and light. Check the colour of the injector body, look for cracks, and read the indicator light, which can show the injector as expired or empty.

When you point out the right problem, the seller lowers the price: the video shows it at 00:02:56, and the tool gives the discount for a good inspection as 15%.

Food Stamps: value, seal and chip checks

Community reported AllThingsHow’s guide and Wikily’s handbook transcription agree on this checklist. Both reference the game’s handbook; this is not independent testing by this site.

Printed valueExpected security seal
40, 80 or 120 creditsNo seal
160, 200 or 240 creditsSeal required
Any other denominationNot a valid Food Stamp value

Inspect before paying. Match the lettering and logo against your current handbook, then check the chip. A missing or damaged chip makes the stamp unusable, even if it is genuine; damage and counterfeiting are separate issues. Use the printed denomination for the seal check, not the seller’s asking price.

Can you redeem a fake at the Commissary? AllThingsHow says no. In an older Steam discussion, Yggdrasil Burnes also reports in reply #3 that counterfeit or spent stamps do not work there. That reply is from the Playtest period, not a new 1.0 test.

Hemingway Cigarettes: counterfeit checks

Single source The full checklist below comes from AllThingsHow’s cigarette guide. This site has not inspected a pack in game.

  1. Lettering: compare spelling, font and alignment with the handbook.
  2. Logo: compare the emblem with the genuine example.
  3. Seal: the guide treats a missing or broken seal as counterfeit.
  4. Color: use the Hemingway Color Checker alongside the magnified pack.

The Steam color-checking thread adds practical detail: ZeldaFreak (#3) suggests matching each swatch to the corresponding area. Art (#5) reports overlooking a slight difference in the red on a fake pack. A pack looking close at first glance is not enough to settle it.

Once you identify a specific fault, AllThingsHow’s procedure is to select its matching check and press Confront. Compare first; do not guess a fault merely because the seller calls the pack counterfeit.

Appraiser commission by rank

Recreational Suffering’s tool gives the fee for an appraisal as a base fee plus a percentage of your estimate, both rising with your appraiser rank. Only the Junior Appraiser row has a second source: Piranowsky’s Playtest-era video gives the same 20 base fee plus 15% at 00:11:14. The other three ranks come from the tool alone.

RankBase feeShare of the estimate
Junior Appraiser Community reported2015%
Appraiser Single source4018%
Senior Appraiser Single source6021%
Master Appraiser Single source10025%

Worked examples

These are this site’s own arithmetic on the reported rules, not examples taken from any source and not values checked in game.

Version and sources

The three original valuation sources span the game’s history: Piranowsky’s video is from the Playtest (2026-09-21), Recreational Suffering’s video went up on 2026-10-23, shortly before 1.0, and Minder43’s calculator was released for 1.0, with version 1.1 on 2026-10-31. Recreational Suffering’s tool page says its data comes from the 1.0 release build. For Cybernetic Hands and Ribwiches, all three sources give the same numbers wherever they cover the same row, which makes it likely that 1.0 did not change those rules. Plasma Cartridges are different: the two 1.0-period tools agree with each other apart from the seal wear conflict, but the Playtest video uses smaller figures. No source here is from the developer, so none of this is a confirmation. Sources were last checked on 2026-11-02, and a game update can change any of these values.

Food Stamp and Hemingway references were checked separately on 2026-11-06. AllThingsHow’s two guides are dated 2026-10-29; the Wikily transcription does not state a game version. The cigarette thread is from November 2, while the fake Food Stamp reply is from the September Playtest. These additions do not reverify the older item-value tables.

Left out on purpose: any claim about how often cartridges come without a seal, individual appraisals shown in the videos, and when each in-game appraisal guide unlocks. None of those has a second source yet.

Probably Stolen appraisal FAQ

How do you check Food Stamps in Probably Stolen?

Community references list six denominations: 40, 80, 120, 160, 200 and 240. The first three have no security seal; the last three require one. Compare the print and logo with your handbook. A missing or damaged chip makes even a genuine stamp unusable.

How do you spot fake Hemingway Cigarettes?

AllThingsHow reports four checks: lettering, color, logo and an intact security seal. Use the Magnifying Glass and compare with the handbook and color checker. Steam players warn that a small color mismatch can be easy to miss. These are community reports, not tests by this site.

How do you get appraisal customers in Probably Stolen?

Two release-era community guides say to join the appraisal committee when its representative visits, then put the membership certificate in the display case. They report different arrival times: day 8 on one Apprentice/challenge run and about day 5 in an achievement guide that does not state a difficulty. Treat those days as reports, not a fixed appointment. The certificate needs to be displayed rather than stored in your files.

How do you tell a fake Immunivax in Probably Stolen?

Check the serial number first: one community tool says a genuine one is exactly seven digits with no letters, with a batch (its first three digits) between 125 and 455, and a missing serial number means a fake. Then read the label letter by letter. The product name must be Immunivax with the same capitals, and the maker name must match the in-game guide exactly. Finally look at the body colour, any crack and the indicator light, which can show expired or empty. All of this comes from a single source, Recreational Suffering’s tool and video, and this site has not tested it.

Which Immunivax batch numbers are recalled?

Batches 250, 251, 301, 355, 385, 386 and 421, according to one community tool. The batch number is the first three digits of the seven-digit serial number, so an injector with serial number 3011234 is from recalled batch 301. That tool treats a recalled injector as unusable rather than counterfeit. No second source confirms the list yet.

How are Cybernetic Hands valued in Probably Stolen?

Start from the material: 100 for aluminum alloy, 150 for carbon composite, 300 for gold plated. Add the control interface (Neural +120, EMG+ +45, EMG 0, unspecified −60), take off 35 for wear or 85 for damage, and add 50 for armor and 80 for a blade. A Tactical set adds 100 and a Deluxe set adds 200. The value never drops below 50. Two community tools give identical figures, and a Playtest video matches them where it covers the same entries.

What is the IGN seal worth on a Plasma Cartridge?

Plus 750, more than double the cartridge’s 300 base value, but only on a cartridge with high-grade plasma, no crack, no exposed screws and no reinforced casing. Two community tools agree on that. They disagree on wear: one says any casing wear also cancels the bonus, the other does not check wear at all. If you are buying, price a worn IGN cartridge without the 750 so you do not overpay.

How do you spot a counterfeit Ribwich in Probably Stolen?

Two community tools agree that a Ribwich is fake if its production year is outside 425–429 and 432–438, if its packing facility number is above 35, or if it has a sesame bun without extra pickles or extra pickles without a sesame bun. A wrong or missing Davre logo, or a second-run Ribwich (432–438) without the correct Ribwich sticker, also means a fake, according to one of those tools and a Playtest video. Only one tool adds that a first-run Ribwich with a sticker is fake. A counterfeit Ribwich is worth 40, and so is one with torn or missing packaging.

What are the minimum appraisal values in Probably Stolen?

A Cybernetic Hand never goes below 50 and a Ribwich never below 40; three community sources agree on both floors. A Plasma Cartridge never goes below 90, according to two community tools from the 1.0 period; a Playtest-era video uses a lower floor.

Related pages

Sources